How Purchased Email Lists Can Destroy Your Email Marketing

On paper, a purchased email list can sound like a good idea.

Maybe you’re just getting started with email marketing, or perhaps the list of email addresses you already have has started to go stale.

You have money to spend on marketing. What you don’t seem to have is the time to grow your list on your own.

If someone else is going to do the hard work of collecting email addresses for you, why not take advantage?

Put yourself in the shoes of your customer.

Do you like to receive emails from a business or organization you don’t know? If you see an unfamiliar name in your inbox, are you likely to open and read it? Or do you send it to your trash?

If you’re like most people, you’re protective of your inbox. And while you might not report every unwanted email as spam, you probably don’t think too highly of businesses or organizations that send you email without your permission.

This doesn’t take into account the other setbacks of purchasing a list, like:

1. Purchased lists put you at risk of breaking the law (which can result in steep fines for your business).

The Canadian Anti-Spam Legislation, which went into effect in July 2014, requires you to obtain and document consent before sending commercial emails to Canadian consumers. In the US, the CAN-SPAM legislation also includes some strict regulations around the right and wrong ways to collect email addresses.

2. Purchased lists aren’t allowed by reputable email marketing services

Email marketing services, including Constant Contact, do not allow you to use purchased lists. That’s because we maintain a strong anti-spam policy to ensure that our customers are only sending emails to people who have expressed interest in receiving them.

3. Purchased lists put you at risk of higher spam reports and unsubscribes (and lower open rates)

Not recognizing the name of the sender is one of the biggest reasons people choose to unsubscribe from marketing emails. It’s also one of the main reasons people mark email they receive as spam.

What gets people to open? According to a recent analysis of Constant Contact customer emails, businesses that send personalized emails receive higher open rates than those that send broad messages to their entire list.

Just as the contacts from a purchased list won’t know about your business, you’ll know even less about them. Creating targeted messages from a purchased list is nearly impossible.

What can you do?

The first thing to remember is that even the most time-starved businesses do have the time and resources to build an email list.

It starts with having the right tools to help you collect email addresses in all the places people interact with your business. If you’re a Constant Contact customer, there are three tools you can try out right away:

The benefit of these tools is that they work on their own. You’re already putting in work to increase traffic online and at your business; these tools will help you take advantage of that extra traffic with little extra work.

You can also take things a step further and create a special offer for new subscribers.

Check out this example from needlepoint shoe company, By Paige, which offers a 10% off coupon to new subscribers.

By Paige

After signing up, new subscribers receive an automatic welcome email with the coupon, along with a follow-up reminder message.

By Paige founder, Paige Andrews, explains:

“We definitely noticed people using the coupon. We’re not just adding new sign-ups, it’s also helping to drive sales.”

If you do have marketing budget you want to invest in building your list, there are options for reaching potential subscribers without purchasing an email list.

Facebook advertising is a great example of this. With a tool like Constant Contact’s Facebook Advertising feature, you can promote your email on Facebook to reach users who haven’t Liked your Page and aren’t subscribed to your email list.

This will not only get your great content in front of thousands of potential customers but — by adding a link to your sign-up form to your email — you’ll have an easy way to capture new leads for your business.

This is something that worked well for DineBestForLess.com.  They used Facebook Advertising to promote their emails and attracted hundreds of new email subscribers in less than two months.

Dine Best

Build your email lists the right way

Email marketing relationships can be one of your most valuable marketing assets. In fact, 91 percent of consumers want to receive emails from the organizations they do business with.

Building these relationships starts with making sure you have permission before adding someone to your email list.


This entry was posted on Wednesday, September 30th, 2015 at 10:54 am and is filed under News & Updates. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Responses are currently closed, but you can trackback from your own site.

Comments are closed.